Conditional Immortality - Biblical Proof of Annihaliation in Hell by Douglas B. - HTML preview

Chapter 11

What some reviewers have said about a classic book

on this topic:

The reviews below were taken from Edward Fudge's own web

site (www.edwardfudge.com) located under "written ministry" and about his book "The Fire that Consumes". I place them here only for you to see as items of interest. If you visit his web site, you will see that he is acquainted with best selling author Max Lucado. Additionally, the forward to this book was written by the great evangelical scholar F.F. Bruce.

In his more than 45 years as a pastor, teacher and lecturer, Edward Fudge has written and published numerous books and articles. In the mid-1980s, he began his pursuit of a law degree, which he earned from the University of Houston Law Center in 1988. He is a member of the American Bar Association, Houston Bar Association and State Bar of Texas.

Also, Edward Fudge has been recognized by both "Who's Who in Law" and "Who's Who in Religion." His book on this subject is a classic read by many scholars.

COLIN BROWN, Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, Calif.: "A very strong case for rethinking the notion of the eternal torture of all the lost."

F. F. BRUCE (Deceased), University of Manchester, England: "While this subject is one on which there is no unanimity among evangelical Christians, it is at the same time one on which they have often engaged in fierce polemic. What is called for, rather, is the fellowship of patient Bible study, the fruit of which Mr. Fudge presents here."

74

LYNN MITCHELL, University of Houston, Texas: "One of the most important books produced by conservative evangeli-cals in the 20th century."

JOHN W. WENHAM (Deceased), Oxford, England: "The au-thor is biblical, reverent and fair, showing soundness and inde-pendence of judgment. He makes his main points with force and persuasiveness."

CLARK H. PINNOCK, McMaster Divinity College, Hamil-ton, Ontario: "I know of no book which answers this powerful case."

W. WARD GASQUE, Eastern College, Philadelphia: "An im-portant and thought-provoking book that gives careful atten-tion to the actual words of Scripture."

DALE MOODY (Deceased), The Southern Baptist Theologi-cal Seminary, Louisville, Ky: "I know of no biblical passage which, interpreted rightly and in context, conflicts with the conclusions of this book."

THOMAS H. OLBRICHT (Retired), Pepperdine University, Malibu, Calif: "Evidence for the common assumption that the wicked will suffer eternal conscious torture may not be as con-clusive as assumed."

JOHN F. WALVOORD (Retired), Dallas Theological Semi-nary: "The most extensive study [of the subject] in recent years . . . commendably brings into the discussion many items that are often overlooked." (Note: Dr. Walvoord expressly dis-agrees with the conclusions of this book.) GEORGE LEONARD GOSS, former editor, Evangelical Book Club: "A thorough and convincing exposition."

NEW OXFORD REVIEW: "Exceptionally evenhanded, force-ful and to the point."

75

MISSION JOURNAL: "A formidable scriptural argument which defenders of the popular view will be hard pressed to meet."

EVANGELICAL BOOK CLUB: "A thoughtful case for an opinion that deserves a hearing."

RESURRECTION MAGAZINE: "The definitive work on conditional immortality."

CHURCH OF ENGLAND NEWSPAPER: "Essential reading for anyone interested in the subject."

Also to be noted, in 1992, the (then) most recent global evan-gelism "Lausanne Conference" approved a revised Statement of Faith to allow for Conditional Immortality. This was partly as a result of a number of well-known Christian leaders, such as John Stott, Archbishop George Carey, Philip Hughes, Michael Green, Stephen Travis, Greg Boyd and Clark Pinnock having declared support for part, or all, of what we call condi-tional immortality.

76

The following are ACTUAL comments left on the Guestbook page of the website www.jewishnotgreek.com reprinted here to show you how important this topic is: ==============================

Hello, my name is John and I have been a pastor of several small Bap-tist Churches in the past. I have a degree in religion from Oklahoma Baptist University and attended Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Eventually I got into other lines of work. I have been think-ing about getting back into the ministry if possible lately... but I de-cided not to for a while because I realized that my spiritual life is not what it used to be. Part of the problem is that I have been feeling for a couple of years that I am not close to God like I should be. At times I feel upset with God. I finally realized that the reason is that the doc-trine of hell is making me feel that either God is not truly a God of love... or that if He is then the Bible is incorrect in teaching that God will torture the unsaved for eternity. Either way this represents a seri-ous crisis of faith. The logical inconsistency at times seems to be driv-ing me almost insane. The doctrine of hell as understood by tradition and by most in my churches has been bothering me daily for most of my life. Because of my training I know a little about Greek and about church history and about Jewish and Greek and Roman tradition. So I can tell that you are correct in most, if not all of your arguments. I am beginning to think that what you are teaching is really the truth. I feel a great sense of hope that my attitude toward God will begin to im-prove as I begin to understand Him better. Keep up the good work and I will try to study the subject more. Thank you for your work and may God bless you.

- John.

============================== Hi there,

Just want to say thanks for your huge article on hell. I have been struggling with this for many years – almost to the point of losing my faith. It’s terrifying to understand how a tradition can be so ingrained in us that we can’t see the wood for the trees.

77

I came to your site through a forum run by one who takes the tradi-tional view on hell. I have also been reading John Stott - I haven’t actually got to the end of your writing but am well into the process.

It’s like scales falling from my eyes and also like a great weight has been lifted.

Thanks again

Stephanie

==================================== Dear Brother:

I cannot even begin to describe the catharthis my mind, body and soul went through while reading this book. You may have saved my life and/or my sanity as a result.

You see, i live in San Francisco, and recently renewed my quest for religious truth. Such quest occured after attending a very blasphemous Easter event hosted by a local organization called the sisters of perpetual indulgence (i purposely did not capitalize their name, because i do not respect or admire their work).These sisters (actually men is elaborate drag) essentially mocked God and the Lord Jesus Christ by encouraging lascivious and offesnive behavior, and even had a 'sexy jesus' contest, not at all befitting to the Son of Man.

My quest led me into the darkest spiritual prison imaginable, and consumed my every waking moment. I rapidly descended into a confusing world of evangelical christianity, which on the one had told me that there is a loving God that wants me to love him with all my heart and mind, but that it's unlikely that all my efforts with result in salvation- and my punishment would be spending eternity burning with billions of others. This warped view created in me a sense of anxiety and paranoia i've never known before. I even had thoughts about leaving my family and moving into the woods so i would get away from all the ungodly people i was around, including family. I had terrible thoughts that my daughter might be better off dead, because God wouldn't allow an innocent child to burn in hell for all of eternity. I thought of departed family members roasting in the lake of fire 78

because they were catholics, and all catholics were deceived by false doctrines, and therefore by extension were worthy of eternal torment.

Out of desperation, i tried to correct my sinking ship by doing good works and praying often, which is certainly a good thing and something i'll continue doing for the rest of my life. However, the huge difference is that i was previously doing it not so much out of love (although i told myself this), but out of sheer terror. I was en route to the loony bin, suicide or heart attack if i continued. My family was scared of the monster that i had become- albeit a softly spoken monster, but one nonetheless. I finally decided to search out opposing positions, because i just could not believe that a loving God would allow the majority of those that ever lived to be subjected to an eternity of horrible pain. That's when i found your site and book. My anxiety slowly started to dissipate, i was able to eat again, i no longer scared everyone in my family, and i started to develop a genuine love for our merciful heavenly father.

I'm not sure if the scar of this experience will ever go away, but I'm sure glad to have come out on the other side still intact.

My faith is Jesus Christ has never been stronger, and i look forward to continuing a loving relationship with him.

Thanks for listening and God be with you,

D-

San Francisco, CA

==========================================

Thank you for an awesome and thorough site on this subject. I've believed this for years after coming to the truth through Fudge's book in part but mainly just sitting down with a bible and a concordance. Much prayer and study made it obvious.

The Body of Christ needs this. It has certainly made me more evangelistic and love God more knowing this important truth. Keep up the fine work. Blessings to you and all holding and sharing this!

79

Ted

============================================

Thank you!! I came across this website a few weeks ago as I started researching the topic of hell, whether it's eternal torment or eternal destruction.

At first I stood firm in my belief about hell being eternal torment, but it started to sink more in my head of the simple clarity of the words death and destruction for the unsaved. It intrigued me and I began doing more research online. Your website is the most well-done one I have come across so far and have thoroughly enjoyed learning from it and I often go back to re-read sections or get references.

It's comforting to know that there are other Christians out there who believe in this.

Eternal torment has always disturbed me and honestly has always been something I hated about God, even though I love my Savior, and eventually caused me to distance myself from Him several years ago after having my first child. My son was the most precious thing to me and it infuriated me even more that God would allow souls to be born just to be tormented forever if they ended up not choosing Christ before dying, and that I didn't hold the fate of my son's soul in my hands.

One day as I pondered this matter and was thinking bitterly to God about it, I felt His amazing love once again, just like He always shows it, and felt this great sense of peace and Him telling me that I didn't need to worry, that He is God. I felt so relieved even though I didn't understand, and little did I know that about a year later He would prompt me to step outside of my traditional box and dare to learn from someone else's perspective.

Your website is very easy to read and understand...very uncomplicated and very knowledgeable. Makes far more sense now. Growing up I do remember always finding it very odd that Jesus' death on the cross took the place of mine, because in the back of my head, I was like, but his dying was a few hours of agony, certainly not eternity in torment. And I

80

always found it odd that death actually meant a continual state of dying.

Thank the Lord for your website. I will enjoy getting to meet you someday in eternity :) You helped change the way that I will now be sharing part of the Gospel to others.

Mary

==================================

Hi,

I'm from Australia.

Thanks so much for your site. My love for God has dramatically increased! Now I'm able to have more confidence in telling others about God's love and that He doesn't torture people forever in hell even though eternal destruction is not to be taken light with. Thanks for solidly biblically refuting the traditional view on hell.

I felt a sense of relief when you addressed Revelation 20:10 because out of all past pro-Conditional Immortality articles I've read, you are the only one that addressed and succesfully explained it. Again thanks very much for your efforts.

Ron

================================== Great article.....

Fudge's book was pivotal in helping me understand this true doctrine.

Kim

================================== I am very glad that I came upon your site. I came to the same conclusion a few years ago after losing my grandfather who was a devout Catholic. I began to research the subject to really find out that no one except our Lord has immortality, and that this is the gift that He promises to those who believe in His beloved Son. But I find it extremely hard that most people who claim to believe in the word of God embrace so many false doctrines.

81

It is also difficult because they believe that what I share is something new, and pretty much suggest that I sound like a heretic, propagating false doctrines. I feel at peace with God now more than ever knowing more of his true nature, and this gives me the boldness that I never had before, because even tough I believed the Bible, I always had this burden about this doctrine that I could not get rid of. I just wish that I could meet believers of like mind on this issue.

If you know of any groups of believers like this I would appreciate if you could let me know who they are. I live near Barrie, Ontario, Canada.

God bless you!

Etienne

================================== Thank you so much for your website and for the wealth of solid biblical insight you have given.

I grew up attending several different denominations of Christian churches, and I was taught the traditional view of hell. All the churches I have attended as an adult have taught the traditional view.

I've always wondered why the word, "perish" didn't actually mean "perish" or "be destroyed". I was taught that it meant "be eternally tormented". I have always wondered why the Bible said eternal life was a gift if it was something we already were going to have no matter where we ended up. Now I know I was right to question these things.

Paul never preached about eternal torment, only of the gift of eternal life one could receive by putting their faith in Jesus. How sad it is that so many people only hear of a God that will send them to hell where He will torment them eternally instead of the God who gives eternal life as a gift because of His great love.

Heidi

================================== I got saved in 1984-from a NA background-I didn't believe in hell-we

82

had reincarnation & karma. I read Mary K Baxter & Bill Weiss bks & didn't like them. Those bks are horrific-they're portrayal of God & Jesus didn't seem the same as the Bible.

Most bks about hell teach the traditional view. I only heard of conditional immortality last year through "lamb & Lion" website-David Reagan. As I trusted his view on prophecy I have decided to check it out for myself.

I have read all of hell-know-I'm looking up the passages still-excellent stuff. I'd read Isaiah 66:24 many times and always read it as a view into hell-which I think Perry Stone teaches as well-but it says Dead Bodies-not souls in hell.

City of Adelaide-

S.A-Australia

================================== I can see that we haven't quite left the dark ages yet; we are in need of a second reformation.

May this article put us a big step closer to the end of the dark night we are in.

Chuck

==================================

Congratulations on your excellent site! After reading the information on your site, I am now 100% convinced that what you are saying is the biblical truth. God Bless.

Ioana

A Christian from Romania.

================================== I came to the same conclusion through personal study. I don't understand why the majority of believers either can't or don't want to believe this message.

Dr. Rogers

83

================================== Thankyou!

The traditional teaching on Hell lead me away from Christianity when I was younger, but I am now beginning to see the truth. God bless.

Nikolas

A Quaker from the UK

84

For further reading:

1) www.rethinkinghell.com excellent information written by

evangelicals.

2) The Conditional Immortality Association of New Zealand has

excellent information on their website

http://www.afterlife.co.nz/

3) For a wonderful summary of the Biblical Doctrine of

"Conditional Immortality" visit

http://www.truthaccordingtoscripture.com and look under "The truth about death" link.

4) Also – visit www.hellhadesafterlife.com for excellent

information on Sheol, Hell and more.

5) WWW.EDWARDFUDGE. COM On a more seminary level, the classic book by the late Edward Fudge "The Fire that

Consumes" is also highly recommended (see reviews above).

Visit his web site for more articles on this topic. UPDATE:

Edward Fudge had released his latest book defending

Conditional Immortality. It is called HELL: A Final Word. It

can be found on Amazon.

6) ADDITIONALLY. A full length motion picture was completed

about Edward Fudge’s Life called HELL AND MR. FUDGE.

Just Google - Hell and Mr. Fudge movie for more information.

7) An excellent article by noted Evangelical scholar Clark

Pinnock may be read free online

www.jewishnotgreek.com/Pinnockarticle.pdf

8) For hundreds of detailed pages on this topic - visit

www.jewishnotgreek.com/Robertwr.pdf

William West has put a great deal of research into his book "The Resurrection and Immortality”.

85

THANK YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME TO READ THIS BOOK.

If it has be of a help to you, please feel free to contact the author at

info@Jewishnotgreek.com

Any corrections or printing errors that you notice can be addressed in future editions. Bringing them to my attention would be appreciated.

Many hours of research and emotion were put into this book.

I pray it is a rich blessing to each reader.

86